Marshall Crenshaw says he’s done writing songs: “Sometimes things are just over — and that’s okay”
The power-pop songwriter has been mining his archives, but says he’s no longer compelled to make new music: “I like my life a lot. It’s a cool life”
Marshall Crenshaw has been in deep catalog-digging mode the past few years. He’s released expanded editions of his first two albums — 1982’s Marshall Crenshaw and the following year’s Field Day — and he has 1985’s Downtown and 1989’s Mary Jean & 9 Others on the runway for 2027. He also mined the vaults for The Wild Exciting Sounds of Marshall Crenshaw: Live in the 20th and the 21st Century, while this year saw The Bootleg Sounds of Marshall Crenshaw: 1984–87, a potpourri of unreleased recordings from that period.
Prolific as he’s been in the rearview mirror, however, Crenshaw says that he’s “kind of getting to the end; my archives are kind of empty now.” But, he adds, that doesn’t mean fans should expect to start hearing new music any time soon.
“I kinda stopped writing,” Crenshaw tells us via Zoom from his home in upstate New York. “The last thing I did was a single in 2020, ‘Will of the Wind,’ which is a good song about the state of the world. There will be a reissue of that next Record Store Day, a remixed A-side, and I found something to put on the B-side of it.
“But nothing new now. I don’t feel compelled to write, and if I don’t feel compelled to, then I shouldn’t do it, ’cause songwriting has always been kind of a trial for me. It wears on me; I just give ’til it hurts, kind of. I can’t just do it casually. I can’t just sit down and go, [sings] ‘bah bah bah bah... Oh, there it is!’”
Additionally, he explains, “my ears take a beating when I’m doing that, too, which I don’t need at my age. If I wanted to do it, I guess I could. But I’m not there.”
If that seems like a dramatic assertion, rest assured that Crenshaw is sanguine about the prospect of never writing again.
“Sometimes things are just over — and that’s okay,” he says. “I have a really good catalog, so I can still go out and play. And I just love getting out and playing the stuff — just getting in the moment with it at shows and amusing myself playing in a rock and roll band.
All the latest guitar news, interviews, lessons, reviews, deals and more, direct to your inbox!
“Really, I’m just glad I’m alive, ’cause show business is really tough, and it does kill people. But it didn’t kill me, and it didn’t really hurt me, either — that I can ascertain. It still feels pretty all right, all these years later.”
The Bootleg Sounds surfaced first as a Record Store Day special during April and came out wide last month. The 14 tracks — discovered while compiling the Downtown and Mary Jean reissues — are whole and partial, including live renditions of “Try,” “This Is Easy” and Jackie Wilson’s “Reet Petite,” and an instrumental track of “Blues Is King” made for a TV appearance.
Also notable is a rendition of Buddy Holly’s “That’ll Be the Day,” produced by the E Street Band’s Garry Tallent, with Max Weinberg on drums; it was considered for the 1987 film La Bamba, in which Crenshaw portrayed Holly and instead performed “Crying, Waiting, Hoping.”
“Nobody seemed to know what song Buddy was supposed to sing in the movie, so we tried different ones,” Crenshaw remembers. “It was Garry’s idea to do ‘Crying, Waiting, Hoping.’ I said to him, ‘Buddy never released that song during his lifetime. He wrote it in his apartment before he went out on tour,’ and Garry said, ‘Who gives a shit. Let’s just do it. It’ll be fun’ and blah, blah, blah.
“I never expected them to pick that one for [the movie], but they did. I still had ‘That’ll Be the Day’ around, and I just thought it’s a great version. It’s just live, no overdubs — just how we played it in the room.”
Another grail on the set is Crenshaw’s home recording of “(We’re Gonna) Shake Up Their Minds,” which became source material for the late Kirsty MacColl’s “All I Ever Wanted” on her Electric Landlady album in 1991.
“When I was writing ‘We’re Gonna Shake Up Their Minds,’ I had a panic moment, and I said something to Kirsty like, ‘What if I send you this track that I’m working on, and maybe you can help me make a song out of it.’ A bunch of time went by before I heard anything from her — maybe four weeks or something — and in the meantime I finished my song. Then I got her song, ‘All I Ever Wanted,’ that was written on top of my backing track.”
Somehow, Crenshaw ended up recording his demo of “We’re Gonna Shake Up Their Minds” over MacColl’s demo for “All I Ever Wanted.” That made for a surprise when he played through his tapes while assembling The Bootleg Sounds.
“Right after that recording played, suddenly I heard the voice of Kirsty MacColl, much to my surprise,” Crenshaw says. “And it was a nice surprise, too. I had accidentally recorded over her demo, so I only have a half of it that I was able to put on this album. I wish I had all of it now, but that was a pretty good find right there. That made me really happy to find it.”
Even without writing new music, Crenshaw is keeping himself busy. He’s touring with his own band on a regular basis and is still doing occasional gigs with Smithereens. He’s also continuing to work on a documentary about legendary ’60s record producer Tom Wilson and his work with Bob Dylan, Simon & Garfunkel, Frank Zappa and others.
“Y’know, I have a positive view of the whole thing, like, big-picture-wise,” Crenshaw says. “I’ve achieved longevity!” He laughs. “It was really kinda bumpy getting into show business and all that, but there were so many positive outcomes during the whole time period. I like my life a lot. It’s a cool life. So it’s kind of normal, isn’t it, for people like me to just refuse to lay down until they absolutely have to?”
Gary Graff is an award-winning Detroit-based music journalist and author who writes for a variety of print, online and broadcast outlets. He has written and collaborated on books about Alice Cooper, Neil Young, Bob Seger, Bruce Springsteen and Rock 'n' Roll Myths. He's also the founding editor of the award-winning MusicHound Essential Album Guide series and of the new 501 Essential Albums series. Graff is also a co-founder and co-producer of the annual Detroit Music Awards.